Ridley Scott’s “Hannibal”


One aspect that makes Hannibal quite exceptional, and that should probably be credited to David Mamet’s initial involvement, is its structural concision and the acceptance of those figures as archetypical, preventing the subtextually charged material from becoming too literal on the screen, from overly psychologizing the procedures (as did Demme’s The Silence of the Lambs). Scott makes a clever choice in emphasizing the abundant references to the long Italian tradition in representations which blurry the line between horror, beauty and the grotesque, associating it with the narrative’s batshit grand guignol and occasional discussions of the philosophical or theological implications behind those prevailing images, in the entire city of Florence, as ignored as the people living in it (there is a moment in which a man is murdered in a crowded street, someone looks, but nobody stops, and the policeman can wash his bloody hands in public as if nothing happened, the subsequent killings, even of completely unimportant characters, are given the same unusual attention).

The lost interest in the underlying values of those works reflect a much larger problem, as all institutions are shown to be corrupt and lacking any ethical basis, maybe everyone, as the scenes mentioned above could suggest. Therefore, Giannini’s death scene is fundamental, not just cheap, gratuitous violence. A disemboweled body appears hanging from a balcony, a group of tourists immediately laugh at the incident, then screams are heard and a final shot of the square shows the bystanders perplexed with the view. Suddenly, the representations become a bewildering and horrendous spectacle in flesh and blood, and a forgotten, subconscious understanding of such problems clash into the surface.


In America, the invasion of the modern world by these displaced and almost mythical expressions is even more overt. The same kind of acknowledgement is made in the neo-gothic figure of the villain and his surroundings, portrayed as a deformed monster living in a recluse castle, with faithful servants (the police included) to do the dirty work, in short, Dracula, while Hannibal fancies himself as some sort of savior (and yes, Christ imagery follows), an outlaw punisher who desires the incorruptible purity he sees in Clarice Starling. Their relationship is explicitly related to Beauty and the Beast, to Tristan and Isolde (Wagner’s overture is quoted on the soundtrack at the final encounter), thus, having a deranged love story between investigator and murderer told as a violent fairy tale at its center, it becomes easier to see the parallels with the gialli.

Hannibal‘s inheritance from Dante Alighieri is the same of Mario Bava, but it doesn’t mean Scott tries to simply emulate the Italian masters, which is impossible to anyone who takes the genre seriously, for they are essentially works of criticism. Bava, Sergio Martino, Dario Argento, Lucio Fulci were all film/art critics, none of their best work should be considered mere reproduction, and I think Scott does something very close here, besides the clear awareness of their common aesthetic principles, which is probably what motivates the departure from his vices in other more stylized efforts, oriented by static and saturated images, as opposed to Hannibal‘s more harmonious movements, elegant camera work and gorgeous use of chiaroscuro lighting. And even Hans Zimmer’s main theme sounds like a nod to Goblin’s Suspiria.


Hannibal must be the director’s greatest accomplishment since Blade Runner, and I hope it gets the same critical revaluation after the general dismissal of the film upon release. And to think that something this risky, an outright insane black comedy, constantly refusing to play safe, was put out as a blockbuster by a major studio, with big stars, and done by a director who is far from willing to take big chances most of the times, only 14 years ago… A production like this is unimaginable today, and that is really sad.

Christofer Pallú


7 thoughts on “Ridley Scott’s “Hannibal”

  1. Oh I love your blog (and horror). I ve recently rewatched this one that and loved more than before, noticed too is obviously the inspiration for the angle they took for the NBC serie (more than any other film version…in this season the film in Florence so it should be interesting to watch). I m curious to hear your opinion bout the nbc serie since i cannot make my mind about: siblime by moments and with secret nods to all horro film history and lynch cronenberg (first and second season)…but allway feeling that as a sort postmodern experiment, and not that is anything wrong bout that!!


    • Thanks.

      The problem is I simply can’t keep up watching series, ritually, I get bored, but I’ll check out this one someday, there’s so much going on in Hannibal that I can see all the potential for the TV format.

      • Thanks for the reply, and sorry for my very rushed and horrible english. Indeed series, and serie fans, can be impossible these days…I myself just got into the serie almost by chance: Saw ep 5 of first season (i was expecting this so bad that not even cared bout watching in order since, anyway is all known stuff… and got hooked by curiosity, anyway first episodes are weak I myself would have never go trygh starting in the right order!!!

        An interesting factor is they don`t have the rights for “Silence of Lambs” but they do for Red dragon so they just jazz scramble all the characters playing almost in the repetition and myth cycle, smart and almost postmodern as they say!! :D
        -Here they scramble a little with a scene that appears later in Florence and Hannibal, (it follows with a very funny variation not here) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w2-YAxCPmQQ


  2. Speaking of Horror TV, looks like Wes Craven said (via tweeter) is working in a TV serie based on “People under the stairs”


    • I hope he ends up directing these new TV projects. It’s been some time since Scream 4 and My Soul to Take (which is one of his best) and Craven seems far from done with filmmaking, it’s sad he’s fallen from grace with the studios.

Leave a reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s